The Truth About ‘Diets’ and Why They Don’t Work

In our fast-paced world, the allure of quick fixes for weight loss is stronger than ever. Fad diets, detox programs, and the latest medications promise rapid results with minimal effort. In the press recently, they have been discussing a new weight loss jab which is a medication that has garnered attention for its potential to support weight reduction. While medications might offer some benefits for some people, it’s essential to understand that there is no substitute for the hard work of achieving and maintaining weight loss through sustainable, long-term changes.

As a nutritional therapist, I’ve seen countless individuals frustrated by the ups and downs of restrictive diets and quick fixes. Let’s break down why “diets” don’t work for most people, and why relying on any medication, isn’t the silver bullet many hope it will be.

The Truth About Diets

Diets—especially those focused on extreme calorie restriction or eliminating entire food groups—are often marketed as simple solutions to complex problems. However, the reality is that diets, in their traditional sense, often fail to produce lasting results for several reasons:

1. Diets Are Unsustainable: Most diets are too restrictive to maintain long-term. Cutting out major food groups, reducing calorie intake drastically, or following overly prescriptive eating plans may work in the short term, but they’re not feasible for everyday life. Eventually, people revert to their old eating habits, leading to weight regain. This yo-yo effect, known as weight cycling, can negatively affect metabolism and increase the risk of cardiovascular and metabolic issues.
2. Nutritional Deficiencies: Many fad diets are nutritionally imbalanced. Popular plans like ketogenic or paleo can limit essential nutrients like fibre,     vitamins, and minerals that are vital for overall health. Restricting carbohydrates, for example, can leave you low on energy and missing out on     important gut-healthy fibres. A lack of adequate nutrition can lead to fatigue, irritability, and even long-term health issues.
3. Ignoring  the Root Cause: Diets often focus solely on cutting calories without addressing the underlying causes of weight gain. Hormonal imbalances, emotional eating, stress, and a sedentary lifestyle all contribute to weight issues. Without addressing these factors, any weight loss achieved through restrictive dieting is often temporary.
4. Diets  Encourage a Poor Relationship with Food: Many diets label foods as “good” or “bad,” which can foster an unhealthy relationship with eating.     This restrictive mindset can lead to guilt, shame, and binge eating. Instead of enjoying food as nourishment, people become obsessed with rules, leading to a negative cycle of deprivation and overeating.

Enter Mounjaro: The Latest Weight Loss Jab

Mounjaro (tirzepatide) has gained significant attention for its ability to help people lose weight. Originally developed to manage blood sugar in people with type 2 diabetes, Mounjaro acts on certain receptors in the brain that regulate appetite, which can lead to reduced calorie intake and, subsequently, weight loss.

While Mounjaro has shown promise in clinical trials, it's important to note that it is not a magic solution. Here’s why:

1. Medication Without Lifestyle Changes is Not Enough: While Mounjaro can help suppress appetite and assist with weight loss in the short term, it cannot replace the benefits of a healthy diet, regular physical activity, and sustainable lifestyle changes. Long-term weight loss requires addressing   habits, mindset, and lifestyle factors that medications simply can’t fix. Without these foundational changes, weight regain is likely once the medication is stopped.
2. Side Effects and Risks: Like any medication, Mounjaro comes with potential side effects, including nausea, gastrointestinal discomfort, and, in some   cases, serious complications. Relying on medication as the primary method for weight loss can pose health risks, especially when underlying     nutritional needs are ignored.
3. Temporary Solution to a Lifelong Challenge: Weight management is a lifelong process, and no jab can permanently alter eating habits or fix emotional relationships with food. Mounjaro may help some people jumpstart their weight loss, but unless they adopt long-term changes in their diet and lifestyle, the effects are likely to fade over time.

The Nutritional Therapist’s Approach: Sustainable WeightLoss

From a nutritional therapist’s perspective, lasting weight loss is about creating balance, nourishing the body, and developing a healthy relationship with food. Here are some key principles for sustainable weight loss:

1. Eat Real, Whole Foods: Focus on a nutrient-dense diet that includes plenty of fruits, vegetables, lean proteins, healthy fats, and whole grains.     Whole foods provide the body with the nutrients it needs to function optimally, support metabolism, and maintain energy levels.
2. Balance  Blood Sugar Levels: Avoid the spikes and crashes in blood sugar that can lead to cravings and overeating. Incorporate balanced meals with a good mix of protein, fibre, and healthy fats to stabilise your blood sugar and keep you feeling full longer.
3. Address  Emotional Eating: Recognise when emotions, rather than hunger, drive your food choices. Stress, anxiety, and even boredom can lead to     overeating or cravings for unhealthy foods. Mindfulness, stress management, and emotional support can help break the cycle of emotional eating.
4. Focus on Long-Term Habits: Instead of adopting a restrictive diet, focus on long-term, sustainable habits. Gradually introduce healthier foods,     increase your daily activity, and make small, incremental changes that are easy to maintain. This approach leads to consistent progress rather than     quick fixes that don’t last.
5. Physical  Activity: Movement is crucial, not just for weight loss, but for overall health. Incorporating regular physical activity—whether it’s walking, Pilates, or strength training—helps support metabolic health and boosts mood, further reinforcing healthy habits.
6. Personalised  Nutrition: Most importantly everyone’s body is different, and there’s no one-size-fits-all solution to weight loss. Working with a nutritional therapist allows for a personalised approach that considers your unique needs, preferences, and health conditions.

No Shortcuts to Sustainable Weight Loss

While Mounjaro and other medications may have their place, they're not substitutes for the hard work required to achieve lasting weight loss. True health and wellness come from nourishing the body, balancing hormones, addressing emotional factors, and making lifestyle changes that are both realistic and sustainable. Quick fixes, whether through restrictive diets or jabs, can provide temporary results, but the real key to long-term success lies in a holistic, whole-body approach.

Weight loss is a journey, not a race. By focusing on nourishing your body and mind, and making gradual, lasting changes, you can achieve the healthy, balanced life you deserve—without falling into the traps of fad diets or the false promises of a silver bullet solution.

‍